【禁闻】汪洋在美“示弱”? 陆媒为何封杀

【新唐人2014年12月22日讯】日前,中共国务院副总理汪洋,在美国举行的中美商业关系论坛上,坦承引领世界的是美国,中国既无意愿,也无能力挑战美国的地位,不过这些带有示弱色彩的话,在大陆媒体的报导中并没有出现,根据英文稿翻译出来的中文稿在网上也都被删除。那么,为什么中共官媒敢封杀副总理的言论,我们来看看。

12月17号,中共国务院副总理汪洋,出席在美国芝加哥举行的第25届中美商贸联委会会议,并发表了主题演讲。汪洋在演讲中说,“中美是全球经济的伙伴,但引领世界的是美国”。

随后他还补充说,虽然中国经济总量已经是全世界第二大,但只有美国的55%,人均GDP也只有美国的八分之一。中国没有想法、也没有能力挑战美国地位。

大陆时政评论员陈明慧:“汪洋讲的是大白话,也是大实话,一方面表示他的坦承,第二,向美国也是一种示弱,第三为了达到访问的一些结果,表示一个友好, 同时也是代表当局习近平先生的意图,来传达这么一个信息。”

大陆时政评论员陈明慧指出,中共当局面临内外交困,目前最大的任务是维持政权的稳定。陈明慧说,俄罗斯的形势更加让他们认识到,如果和美国叫板,会带来更多很多内外麻烦,和付出不必要的代价。汪洋希望通过这番话告诉美国,中共当局没有称霸世界的意图,也没有输出共产主义的打算,这样能够缓解在国际社会相对孤立的局面。

《亚洲新闻周刊》总监黄金秋:“中国目前确确实实也没有能力挑战美国,之所以在美国这样讲,主要是传达一个信息,中国不会成为一个侵略者,或者是不会成为经济上的一个掠夺者,是要西方放松对中国的这种警惕之心,当然也比较务实。”

《新华社》在英文报导中,还提及了汪洋在演讲中说的,“引领世界的是美国”,以及“人均GDP只有美国的八分之一”等说法。不过在《新华社》的中文报导中,这些有关示弱的内容全部遭到删除。

报导强调的是,美方愿意在相互尊重和互利基础上,同中方加强合作,增进了相互理解,达成了多项共识。

黄金秋:“十八大以来,所谓的爱国主义抬头,民族主义抬头,官员为了试图转移老百姓的注意力,转移视线,要煽动仇日、反美这样一个情节,在这样一个大环境下,汪洋的讲话如果在国内报导,就会被司马南这种五毛迎头痛击,原来国家领导人都承认美国在世界经济的领导地位,成天反美不是很搞笑的事情了嘛。”

陈明慧:“国内的主流媒体整天宣传的都是假大空,虚假的东西,跟汪洋副总理说的完全是背道而驰的,它不能说自己说谎圆不了,自己打自己的嘴巴,只能说都屏蔽掉,都删除。”

汪洋在演讲中还表示,美国已经主导了体系和规则,中国愿意加入这个体系,也尊重这个规则,希望从中发挥“建设性作用”。

陈明慧:“共产党会根据现阶段它的需求作出种种的承诺,一旦危及到它的统治地位,它立刻把所有的承诺都抛弃,过去无论是加入WTO还是 签署了《联合国人权宣言》,都违背了。”

国内网友对汪洋在美国的这些演讲,也有许多议论,有网友认为汪洋“代表了开放、务实和全球化视野下的国务院的声音,和红色党的意识形态不一样”。也有网友批评说,“靠服软换取美国的恩赐简直就是痴心妄想。”

海外中文媒体说,汪洋这番谈话据传遭到了高层领导批评,说汪洋的演讲是为了听掌声,博笑声,忘记了代表国家的身份,要求汪洋做好总结检查。

不过也有评论认为,鉴于俄罗斯因为遭到制裁经济“千疮百孔”,可能带来的“共振效应”,汪洋能够正视自身实力,谦和的态度是最好的保护色。

采访编辑/刘惠 后制/萧宇

Party Propaganda Media Blocked Wang Yang’s
Speech for “Sign of Weakness" in America.

Chinese Communist Party (CCP) Vice Premier Wang Yang
recently spoke at the opening ceremony of a China-U.S.
business forum.

In his speech, Wang admitted that the U.S. is still playing
a global leading role.

He said, “China has neither the intention nor the capability
to challenge America’s leading status."

However, Wang’s words showing weakness were not
mentioned by any mainland Chinese media.

Reports translated from English ones were also deleted
on the Internet.

Why did the CCP block speeches of its vice premier?
Let’s look at the following report.

On Dec.17, the CCP’s Vice Premier Wang Yang attended
the 25th session of the U.S.-China Joint Commission on
Commerce and Trade (JCCT) in Chicago and spoke at the
opening address.

Wang stressed that “China and the U.S. are business
partners in global economy.

But it is the United States that is leading the world."

Wang added that “China’s economic aggregate, although
already number two in the world, is just 55 percent of
that of the US, and China’s per capita GDP is merely
one eighth of the U.S. level."

Wang stressed “China has neither the intention nor the
capability to challenge America’s leading status".

Chen Minghui, Chinese political commentator, “Wang Yang
is simply telling the truth.

Both to show his frankness and a sign of weakness.

Those are also friendly comments as a visitor, to reach some
deals and possibly a message for CCP president Xi Jinping."

Chen Minghui comments that, the CCP is facing huge
difficulties both from inside and outside China.

The most important thing for the party now is to maintain
“stability" of its regime.

Chen said, CCP leaders may learn from Russia that taking on
America will be more trouble than benefit,

Wang Yang hoped to deliver the message with his speech that
the CCP has no intention to challenge America.

Nor does it intend to promote its Communism theory.

The main purpose was to ease the CCP’s isolation
from the world, said Chen.

Huang Jinqiu, director of Asian News Weekly, “There is no
doubt the CCP is currently not able to challenge the U.S..

Wang spoke like that in the U.S. to pass on a message
that China wont be an invader or a plunderer in economy.

It serves to relax western countries’ vigilance against China.
Of course it is also a realistic statement."

In its English report, the Xinhua News Agency quoted
Wang Yang’s words including “America is leading the world"
and “China’s per capita GDP is merely one eighth of
the US level".

However, all speeches showing a sign of weakness have
been deleted in Xinhua’s report in Chinese.

The Chinese version of the Xinhua report stressed that the
United States is willing to enhance cooperation with China.

On the basis of mutual respect and benefit;

the forum promoted understanding between both countries
and consensus have been reached on many issues.

Huang Jinqiu, “Since the CCP 18 National Congress,
patriotism and nationalism have again become popular.

CCP officials have been working on inciting hatred against
Japan and America, to distract Chinese peoples’ attention.

In this situaiton, if Wang’s speech is reported in China,
it will be heavily criticized by leftists such as Sima Nan.

Anti-Americanism will become a joke if Chinese people learn
that even CCP leaders have admitted America’s leading
role in the global economy."

Chen Minghui, “Chinese media are repeating empty talks
day and night.

Wang Yang’s words are completely opposed to this style.

Since the party cannot slap its own mouth, the only option
is to block all relevant reports in Chinese."

In his address, Wang Yang also said America has dominance
over various rules shaping the world order.

China “basically accepts these rules and are willing to play
a constructive role in the global economic structure,
established under the US leadership".

Chen Minghui, “The CCP can make any kind of
promise if necessary.

However, once its regime is threatened, it can backpedal on
any commitments in no time.

In the past, it never kept its words when joining WTO
or signing the Universal Declaration of Human Rights."

In discussing Wang Yang’s speech in U.S., Chinese netizens
have different opinions.

Some said the address “represent an open and realistic
attitude of the State Council with from a globalized
viewpoint, which is very different from the CCP’s
red traditions".

There is also criticism such as “It is wishful thinking to expect
favor from the U.S. by saying something showing weakness".

According to Overseas Chinese media, Wang Yang was
said to have been criticized by party leaders for the sake
of “speaking for applause instead of his country". The report
said, Wang was required to make self-criticism for that.

There are other comments saying that, Russia’s economy
has been seriously struck under economic sanctions;

Considering its resonance effect, Wang Yang’s realistic
and modest attitude can be a good way of self-protection.

Interview & Edit/LiuHui Post-Production/XiaoYu

相关文章
评论